Better Alternatives to Selling on Etsy That Will Help Expand Your Art Empire

While Etsy has been a popular platform for creators and artisans, it’s always a good idea to explore other options and diversify your online sales channels.

Let’s delve into why you might look for alternatives to selling on Etsy and what aspects to consider when choosing a new sales platform.

Why You Might Look Alternatives to Selling on Etsy

Etsy is an excellent starting point for many creators.

However, as your business grows, you might find yourself seeking alternatives to Etsy for several reasons.

  1. Fees: Just like any other online marketplace, Etsy charges listing and transaction fees. If your sales volume is high, these fees can add up quickly. It’s always good to compare the cost of selling on Etsy with other platforms.
  2. Control: On Etsy, you are bound by their policies and guidelines. If you prefer to have more control over your brand, pricing, and policies, other platforms could be a better fit.
  3. Competition: Etsy is a large marketplace, and standing out among the crowd can be challenging. By exploring other platforms, you might find a less competitive space for your products.
  4. Customization: Etsy provides limited customization options for your shop’s appearance. If you want a unique and personalized online shop, you might consider other platforms.

Things to Consider When Choosing a Sales Platform

When looking for alternatives to Etsy, consider the following factors:

  1. Fees: Consider the costs involved in using the platform. This includes listing fees, transaction fees, and any additional costs. For example, you might want to compare the cost of selling on Shopify with Etsy.
  2. Ease of Use: The platform should be user-friendly and easy to navigate for both you and your customers.
  3. Customer Reach: Consider the platform’s user base. A platform with a large user base can offer more potential customers.
  4. Features: Look for features that are important for your business, such as inventory management, payment options, shipping options, and customer service tools.
  5. Integration: If you’re using other software for your business (like email marketing tools or accounting software), make sure the platform can integrate with them seamlessly.

Remember, the best platform depends on your business needs and goals. Take the time to research and compare different platforms to find the best fit for your business. You might even consider using multiple platforms to reach a broader audience and increase your sales. Whatever you choose, make sure it aligns with your business strategy and supports your growth.

Online Marketplaces

An artist sits at a desk in her studio wondering about alternatives to selling on Etsy.

When it comes to finding alternatives to selling on Etsy, online marketplaces are a popular choice. These platforms provide an established customer base and a host of features designed to make selling online as straightforward as possible. But, like anything, they come with their own set of pros and cons.

The Pros and Cons of Online Marketplaces

The advantages of selling on online marketplaces are significant. Firstly, these platforms are typically easy to use. You don’t need extensive technical skills to set up a shop and start selling your products. Secondly, they provide exposure to a large audience. This can be particularly beneficial if you’re just starting out and don’t have a large customer base of your own yet.

However, there are also some downsides to consider. For example, there can be heavy competition on these platforms, which can make it harder for your products to stand out. You’ll also need to comply with the rules and guidelines of the platform, which can limit how you present and sell your products. Additionally, selling on these platforms often involves fees, which can eat into your profits. Check out our articles on cost of selling on shopify and cost of selling on etsy to get an idea of what you might be up against.

Large customer baseHeavy competition
Easy to useMust comply with platform rules
Various features to aid sellingFees can eat into profits

Key Features to Look For

When choosing an online marketplace, it’s important to consider what features are most important to you. Here are some things to look out for:

  1. Ease of use: You want to spend your time creating and selling, not struggling with a complicated platform. Look for a marketplace that’s easy to navigate and has a simple process for listing and selling products.

  2. Audience: Make sure the platform caters to the kind of customers you want to reach. Some marketplaces might be more popular with certain demographics.

  3. Fees: Be clear on what it will cost you to sell on the platform. This includes listing fees, selling fees, and any other costs the platform might charge.

  4. Payment options: Look for a platform that offers a variety of payment options to make it easy for customers to purchase your products.

  5. Support: Check what kind of support the platform offers. This could include customer service, seller education, and resources to help you succeed.

As you explore your options, keep your own needs and circumstances in mind. What works for one seller might not work for another, so it’s important to choose a platform that fits your specific needs. Be sure to also check out our tips for selling on shopify and tips for selling on etsy for more guidance.

Self-Hosted Websites

As you explore alternatives to selling on Etsy, one option that stands out is setting up your own self-hosted website. This approach comes with several benefits and considerations.

The Benefits of Selling Through Your Own Website

Having your own website gives you complete control over your online store. Unlike selling through a marketplace like Etsy, where you’re one among many sellers, your website puts your products front and center. This visibility can go a long way in establishing your brand and attracting a loyal customer base.

Here are some benefits of selling through your own website:

  1. Brand Identity: Your website is a space you can customize to reflect your brand’s personality, ethos, and story. This flexibility can help you create a strong brand identity and differentiate yourself from competitors.

  2. Customer Relationships: With your own website, you can directly interact with your customers, respond to their queries, and get their feedback. This direct interaction can help you build strong relationships with your customers and understand their needs better.

  3. Profit Margins: Selling through your own website can help you save on marketplace fees, potentially increasing your profit margins. For more on this, check out our article on the cost of selling on Etsy vs the cost of selling on Shopify.

  4. Marketing Opportunities: With your own website, you can implement various marketing strategies like SEO, content marketing, and email marketing. These strategies can help you reach a wider audience and increase your sales.

What You Need to Know About Setting Up a Website

Setting up a website may seem daunting, but it’s a lot simpler than you might think. Here’s a broad overview of what you need to do:

  1. Choose a Domain Name: This is your website’s address on the internet. It should be simple, easy to remember, and reflect your brand name.

  2. Select a Web Host: A web host is a service that stores your website data and makes it accessible to users. There are many web hosts to choose from, each with different features and pricing plans.

  3. Design Your Website: This involves choosing a website template, customizing it to reflect your brand, adding product pages, and setting up a shopping cart and payment gateway.

  4. Optimize Your Website: This involves implementing SEO strategies to make your website more discoverable by search engines.

Setting up your own website is a significant step towards creating a unique online presence. It allows you to showcase your products in your own unique way and build deeper connections with your customers. For more detailed information and helpful tips, check out our guide on how to start selling on Shopify.

Social Media Sales Channels

As you search for alternatives to selling on Etsy, don’t overlook the power of social media. Social media platforms have evolved beyond communication and networking tools. They now offer creators like you an avenue to showcase and sell your products directly to your followers.

Selling Directly Through Social Media Platforms

Social media platforms such as Instagram and Facebook now have built-in features that allow you to set up shop and sell your products directly. With this method, you can turn your social media profiles into virtual storefronts.

This direct approach to selling has several benefits. Firstly, you can leverage your existing follower base and turn them into potential customers. Secondly, you can interact directly with your customers, answer their queries in real time, and gain valuable feedback. Lastly, the visual nature of social media platforms allows you to showcase your products in an engaging and creative way.

However, remember that selling on social media also requires careful management of your business image. Every post, comment, and interaction becomes a reflection of your brand. So, it’s important to keep your social media presence professional and customer-focused.

What to Consider When Selling on Social Media

When considering social media as an alternative to Etsy, there are a few things to keep in mind:

  1. Platform Selection: Choose a platform where your target customers are most active. You should also consider the product you’re selling. For instance, handmade crafts might perform better on visually driven platforms like Instagram.

  2. Customer Engagement: Engaging with your customers is crucial on social media. Responding to comments, messages, and reviews can build a strong relationship with your audience and boost your brand’s reputation.

  3. Marketing Efforts: Social media platforms offer various advertising and marketing tools. You can use these to reach a wider audience and promote your products.

  4. Payment and Shipping: Unlike Etsy or Shopify, social media platforms may not have built-in payment and shipping options. You’ll need to set up a secure payment method and establish clear shipping and return policies.

  5. Analytics: Use the analytics tools provided by the platform to track your sales, measure customer engagement, and adjust your strategy as needed.

Remember, selling on social media doesn’t have to be a standalone strategy. It can complement your existing sales channels, whether that’s Etsy, Shopify, or your own website. Be sure to check out our articles on how to start selling on Shopify and tips for selling on Etsy for more information about balancing multiple sales channels.

Subscription Box Services

As you explore alternatives to selling on Etsy, one unique and trendy option is subscription box services. These services offer a distinctive approach to online sales, allowing you to offer your products as part of a curated, recurring package delivered directly to customers’ doorsteps.

How Subscription Box Services Work

Subscription box services operate on a recurring delivery model. As a creator, you curate a box of products, which could be anything from handmade crafts, jewelry, or customized items. Customers subscribe to your service, and they receive a new box of your creations at a set interval – usually monthly.

The process starts with customers signing up and choosing their subscription plan. Some services allow customers to customize their box, choosing the types of products they wish to receive or even individual items. Once the customer has subscribed and paid, you compile their box and ship it out. Then, at the start of the next cycle, the process repeats.

This model is appealing to customers because it offers the excitement of receiving new and unique products on a regular basis. For you as a seller, it provides a steady and predictable income stream, as customers commit to purchase from you on a regular basis.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Subscription Services

There are numerous benefits to selling your products via a subscription box service. Some of the key advantages include:

  • Recurring revenue: Unlike standalone product sales, subscription services provide a consistent and predictable revenue stream. This can help stabilize your income and make it easier to plan for the future.
  • Customer retention: Subscription services encourage customer loyalty, as subscribers are making a commitment to your brand on a recurring basis.
  • Increased exposure: By being part of a subscription box, your products can reach a wider audience. This can result in increased brand awareness and potential for additional sales.

However, subscription box services also have some drawbacks:

  • High startup costs: Setting up a subscription service can be expensive. You’ll need to invest in packaging, shipping materials, and potentially hiring help to assemble and ship your boxes.
  • Increased workload: Managing a subscription service can be time-consuming. You’ll need to manage customer subscriptions, curate and pack boxes, and handle shipping and customer service.
  • Challenging to retain subscribers: While subscription services can boost customer loyalty, it can also be challenging to keep customers interested and engaged over time. You’ll need to continuously offer new and exciting products to keep your subscribers satisfied.
Recurring revenueHigh startup costs
Customer retentionIncreased workload
Increased exposureChallenging to retain subscribers

In conclusion, subscription box services can be a great alternative to selling on Etsy. However, it’s important to carefully consider the pros and cons before diving in. As always, the best platform for your products depends on your unique needs, goals, and capabilities. For more guidance on selling online, check out our articles on how to start selling on Shopify and tips for selling on Shopify.

Crafting Your Online Sales Strategy

Once you’ve explored the different alternatives to selling on Etsy, it’s time to formulate your online sales strategy. This process involves choosing the right platforms for your products and balancing multiple sales channels.

Choosing the Right Platforms for Your Products

When deciding on the most suitable platform for selling your products, it’s essential to consider the nature of your products, your target audience, and your business goals.

Online marketplaces might be the perfect fit if you want to reach a broad audience without the need to manage a website. On the other hand, if you want complete control over your brand and customer experience, a self-hosted website might be the best option. If you’re considering a more direct approach to selling, social media sales channels could be the way to go.

It’s also important to consider the cost implications of each platform. For instance, if you’re considering Shopify as one of the alternatives to Etsy, you might want to check out our articles on the cost of selling on Shopify and is selling on Shopify profitable to help you make an informed decision.

Remember that there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. The best platform for your products depends on your unique circumstances and business needs.

Balancing Multiple Sales Channels

While it can be beneficial to sell on multiple platforms, it’s crucial to strike a balance. Managing too many sales channels can dilute your efforts and may not result in the desired growth.

When considering multiple sales channels, think about your capacity to manage them effectively. Each platform will require time and effort to maintain — from listing products to handling customer inquiries and processing orders.

One strategy you might consider is to start with one platform, then gradually expand to others as your business grows. This way, you can focus your efforts on mastering one platform before moving onto the next.

For instance, you could start selling on Etsy and learn from the experience, using our tips for selling on Etsy as a helpful guide. Once you’re comfortable, you could consider branching out to other platforms such as Shopify, using our guide on how to start selling on Shopify for assistance.

Remember, the goal of your online sales strategy should be to find the most effective way to reach your target audience and sell your products. This might involve selling on one platform or balancing multiple sales channels. The choice ultimately depends on what works best for your business.

In the end, choosing the right platforms and balancing multiple sales channels will be key to your success when exploring alternatives to selling on Etsy. With careful planning and strategic decision-making, you can expand your online empire and reach new heights in your business.

Ready to Grow Your Online Store and Build a Living Through Your Creations?

It’s possible to make a living through creating the things that bring you joy.

In this 5-day email course I’ll show you how I approached the creation of my own Shopify store The Gray Muse.

Because I know that you find joy in creating and if you could make money from your creations, how is that not the perfect world?

Get It Today